Why Uncertainty Makes Us Anxious … And What “Sitting With It” Actually Looks Like

Why Uncertainty Makes Us Anxious … And What “Sitting With It” Actually Looks Like

You send an email and don’t get a reply.

Your child says they have a headache.

Your partner seems quiet.

You notice a strange charge on your bank account.

Your brain immediately wants answers.

What does this mean?

Is something wrong?

Should I check?

Should I message again?

Should I Google it?

Uncertainty is uncomfortable.

For anxious people, it can feel almost unbearable.

So we do what seems sensible.

We try to get rid of it.

We check.

We ask.

We Google.

We plan.

We seek reassurance.

We look ahead.

We try to know.

And for a little while, that often works.

Which is exactly why the habit becomes so sticky.

Anxiety loves certainty

Anxiety is basically a threat-detection system.

Its job is to ask: “Is there something here I need to worry about?”

The problem is that uncertainty gives it plenty to work with.

If something is unknown, your brain can fill in the gap.

And anxious brains are rarely known for filling gaps with: I’m sure it’s probably fine.

They tend to go with: What if something is wrong?

So you try to reduce the uncertainty.

You check your email again.

You feel your child’s forehead.

You ask your partner if they’re okay.

You search the symptom.

You reread the message.

You make a plan.

Then another plan.

And your anxiety drops.

Temporarily.

The problem is that avoiding uncertainty teaches your brain that uncertainty is dangerous

If every time you feel uncertain, you immediately do something to remove that feeling, your brain learns:

“Good thing we checked.”

“Good thing we asked.”

“Good thing we Googled.”

“We couldn’t have coped with not knowing.”

Which makes uncertainty feel even harder next time.

And makes checking, reassurance seeking, and planning your go-to’s.

This is why psychologists so often talk about learning to tolerate uncertainty.

Because learning to tolerate uncertainty is one way to get a better handle on anxiety.

Which sounds great in theory

Except “sit with uncertainty” is one of those phrases that can sound very psychologist-y and not remotely practical.

What does that actually mean?

Sit where?

For how long?

Do what?

Are you supposed to just stare at the wall and feel unsure?

Not quite.

“Sitting with uncertainty” usually means not doing the thing you would normally do to get immediate reassurance or certainty.

It means allowing the question to stay unanswered for a while.

And then continuing with your day anyway.

What sitting with uncertainty can look like at work

You finish work at 5.30pm.

At 8pm, you suddenly think:

Did I send that email?

Normally, you open your laptop.

You check.

Maybe you notice another email.

Now you’re working again.

Sitting with uncertainty might look like:

“I’m not completely sure. I’ll check tomorrow.”

Then not checking.

Or:

You send your manager something important and they don’t reply.

Your brain says:

Maybe they hated it.

You want to follow up.

Sitting with uncertainty might mean waiting until the next reasonable work period rather than sending another message just to relieve your anxiety.

You’re not telling yourself: “Everything is definitely fine.”

You’re telling yourself: “I don’t know yet and that’s OK … I can wait.”

What it can look like in parenting

Your child comes home from school quieter than usual.

You ask if they’re okay.

They say:

“Yep.”

Your brain says:

Something’s wrong.

You ask again.

Then later:

“Are you sure?”

Then:

“Did something happen with your friends?”

Then perhaps you message another parent.

Sitting with uncertainty might look like:

“They’ve told me they’re okay. I’ll stay available, but I don’t need to investigate this right now.”

Or your child mentions a mild symptom.

You notice the urge to Google it immediately.

Instead, you follow the sensible medical plan you already have.

You monitor what needs monitoring.

And resist turning one symptom into a late-night internet research project.

That’s uncertainty tolerance.

What it can look like in relationships

Your partner sends:

“Can we talk later?”

Excellent.

An anxious brain can get an entire feature film out of those four words.

What have I done?

Are they angry?

Is something wrong?

You want to message:

“Is everything okay?”

Then:

“Are you upset with me?”

Then perhaps:

“Can you just tell me now?”

Sitting with uncertainty might look like:

“I don’t know what they want to talk about. I’ll know later.”

Then not repeatedly seeking reassurance.

Or you send a friend a message and they don’t reply.

Instead of rereading your message six times looking for something offensive, you allow:

“There are lots of reasons they may not have replied. I don’t know which one it is yet.”

What it can look like at home

You submit a form.

Normally, you check the confirmation email.

Then check again.

Then log back into the portal to make sure it really went through.

Sitting with uncertainty might mean checking once.

Then stopping.

You pay a bill.

Your brain says:

Did I put the right reference number in?

You resist opening the banking app again.

You book a restaurant.

You don’t reread the reservation three times.

You place an online order.

You don’t track it every two hours.

Tiny examples.

But these are exactly how you learn to master uncertainty tolerance.

What it can look like with random questions

This one is incredibly common.

A thought pops into your head:

How long can cooked chicken stay in the fridge?

What does that weird noise in the dishwasher mean?

Is that actor married?

Can you get sunburnt through a window?

And within three seconds, your phone is in your hand.

We’ve become incredibly unused to not knowing things.

Sometimes sitting with uncertainty is as simple as not Googling the question.

Letting it remain unanswered.

Which sounds trivial.

But it isn’t.

It’s practice in tolerating not knowing.

The goal isn’t to stop checking everything

There are times when checking is useful.

You should check whether you locked the door if you genuinely don’t know.

You should follow up an important work issue.

You should seek medical care when appropriate.

You should ask questions in relationships.

The issue isn’t checking itself.

It’s checking primarily to make anxiety go away.

So before you check, as yourself:

“Am I doing this because there’s a practical reason, or because I feel uncomfortable not knowing?”

Sometimes it’ll be both.

But asking the question can help you notice when checking is robbing you of the opportunity to practice sitting with uncertainty.

Try delaying rather than stopping

If you’re someone who checks a lot, going straight to “I’ll never check again” probably isn’t realistic.

Try delaying.

If you want to Google something, wait ten minutes.

If you want to check your work email, wait half an hour.

If you want to ask for reassurance, pause.

Let the anxiety rise a little.

Then notice what happens.

Often, the urge peaks.

Then softens.

Which is an important lesson.

Because what you’re learning is that discomfort can pass even when you don’t immediately resolve it.

Use a “reasonable enough” rule

Anxiety wants certainty.

Life mostly offers probabilities.

So instead of asking:

“Can I know for sure?”

ask:

“Do I have enough information to make a reasonable decision?”

For example:

“I’ve checked the booking once. That’s enough.”

“I’ve asked my child once. I’ll stay available.”

“I’ve sent the email. I don’t need to reread it.”

“I’ve followed the medical advice I was given.”

“Nothing new has happened, so I don’t need to investigate again.”

Reasonable enough is often the antidote to endless checking.

Notice the sentence that usually comes before the checking

Often it sounds like:

I’ll just check quickly.

Or:

It’ll make me feel better.

Or:

Then I can stop thinking about it.

That last one is particularly seductive.

Because sometimes you can.

But if the pattern is repetitive, checking often teaches your brain to come back with another question.

So instead, try thinking:

“I’m uncomfortable, but I don’t actually need more information right now.”

Because you don’t need certainty.

You just need enough confidence to move on without it.

Create uncertainty practice on purpose

This can sound strange, but it works because tolerance grows through exposure.

Try small experiments:

  • send a text without rereading it three times

  • leave a non-urgent email until tomorrow

  • let someone else choose the restaurant

  • don’t check the weather again

  • submit something after one review instead of five

  • don’t Google a harmless question

  • leave a small household decision until later

  • let your partner organise something without supervising.

Start small.

The point isn’t to make life chaotic.

It’s to prove to yourself: “I can feel uncertain and still be okay.”

Expect it to feel uncomfortable

This is important.

If you stop checking and immediately feel calm, lovely.

But that’s not usually how it works.

More often, your anxiety goes:

Excuse me? We normally check now.

You may feel restless.

Distracted.

Tempted.

That doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong.

It means you’re interrupting a well-practised habit.

The learning happens when you experience the discomfort and discover that you don’t need to fix it immediately.

Uncertainty tolerance isn’t about becoming careless

It’s about becoming less dependent on certainty.

You can still plan.

Ask questions.

Prepare.

Check important things.

The goal isn’t to wander through life shrugging:

Who knows?

It’s to notice when your attempts to feel safe are making you more anxious.

And to practise choosing:

Enough information.

Enough checking.

Enough planning.

Then stop.

The real skill is confidence in your ability to cope

Anxiety says: “I need to know what’s going to happen.”

Uncertainty tolerance says: “I don’t know what’s going to happen, but I trust myself to deal with it when it does.”

And that’s a very different kind of safety.

And unlike certainty, it’s actually available.

Because there will always be unanswered emails.

Unclear conversations.

Unknown outcomes.

Children who don’t tell you everything.

Plans that change.

Things you can’t predict.

The goal isn’t to eliminate those.

It’s to stop treating every unanswered question as a problem that needs solving right now.


Our experienced clinicians can discuss your concerns - contact us to learn more.

Dr. Sarah Hughes

Dr. Sarah Hughes is a clinical psychologist and founder of Think Clinical Psychologists. Sarah completed her clinical training at the University of Sydney and holds a Doctorate in Clinical Psychology and a PhD in child and adolescent anxiety disorders. She has 10 years of clinical experience and enjoys working with kids, teens, adults, families, and couples experiencing a wide range of difficulties, including complex and long-standing difficulties.

Next
Next

Why Kids Don’t Listen … And What Actually Helps